Preserving Tomatoes in Canada

September is tomato month. Here is every tested way to put up the harvest — canned whole or crushed, sauce, salsa, frozen, or dried — with the acidity rule front and centre.

September is the single biggest preserving month in Canada, and tomatoes are why. A bumper crop comes in faster than anyone can eat it, and there are four good ways to put it up: water-bath canning, freezing, and drying all earn a place depending on how much freezer and shelf space you have.

One rule governs all the canning here: tomatoes sit right on the pH 4.6 line, and modern low-acid varieties can cross it. Every tested canning recipe adds bottled lemon juice or citric acid to guarantee a safe acidity — bottled, not fresh, because fresh lemons vary too much to rely on. Skip that step and you've made a low-acid food that needs a pressure canner. The same logic is why you can't safely water-bath a meat-and-onion spaghetti sauce.

Not sure which form to make? Whole vs crushed vs diced walks through which suits which winter meal. And if you've seen white sediment settle in the jar, that one explains when it's harmless and when it isn't. Every recipe cites Bernardin or Health Canada and points you at your altitude band. A food mill or tomato strainer turns a bushel into smooth sauce without peeling and seeding by hand.

Related guides

Frequently asked questions

Do I have to add lemon juice or citric acid when canning tomatoes?
Yes. Tomatoes sit right on the pH 4.6 line and modern low-acid varieties can cross it, so every tested Canadian recipe acidifies each jar to guarantee it stays safe for the water bath. Use bottled lemon juice, not fresh — bottled has a consistent acidity, fresh lemons vary too much. The tested amount is 1 tablespoon bottled lemon juice per 500 mL jar, or 2 tablespoons per 1 L jar (or ¼ / ½ teaspoon citric acid). Skipping it makes a low-acid food that needs a pressure canner.
Can I water-bath can spaghetti or pasta sauce with meat, onions, and peppers?
No. Adding meat, onions, peppers, or mushrooms to a tomato base raises the pH above 4.6, turning it into a low-acid food that a boiling water bath cannot make safe. Your two safe options are to pressure can it, or to freeze it. A plain acidified tomato sauce is fine for the water bath; a loaded meat sauce is not.
Should I peel tomatoes before canning?
For most canned tomato products, yes — skins toughen and separate in the jar and can trap air. Peeling is easy: score an X in the base, dunk in boiling water for 30–60 seconds until the skin splits, then slip into ice water and the peels rub off. Drying and some freezing methods do not require peeling.
Is the white sediment in the bottom of my tomato jars safe?
Usually yes. A layer of pale sediment is typically starch and natural minerals settling out, and it is harmless in a jar that sealed properly and shows no other problems. It is only a concern if it comes with a failed seal, an off or sour smell, cloudiness paired with bubbling, or a bulging lid — in which case discard the jar without tasting.

More preserving topics

Or browse the full articles index.